I ended up with the winning bid on em ($3.50 for the pair)
This is exactly what Ive been looking for, so I didnt jinx it by posting in here

Id had no luck finding them so was going to resort to the old style wico Command Control sticks, but was having a ---smurfette--- of a time finding a pair, or even singles that werent rusty. After getting one of the bat style, I havent had much time to hack it apart and use it. This is good though since Ive added 2600 support and some db9 ports I can use the stick as intended, and find another(the bat styles seem abundant on ebay, but not the ball)
Depending on the exact size of the holes, Ive got some barrel type switches that may fit, or do it the ol' Wico way, a long rod that goes thru to the bottom and makes contact with a leaf switch