Okay, I'm out of date than on stuff like this. I barely do this at all anymore.
The HD is dead in my Tivo... the Tivo runs Linux but I forget the exact filesystem. I need to see if the disc really is dead, or just MBR hosed and recoverable. Rather than build a Linux box I'm thinking of using something like this to check the disc:
http://www.fs-driver.org/The main complication I can see is that if I can't read the disc it may be hard to see if it's because of the disc or because the FS driver isn't working.
Any ideas? I figure maybe someone here is more recent in the tools necessary.