So tell me what would be better, i leave it up to you: Pick one thats already been done? (most likely in year one, so that there's been some time between contests) OR just let the 2nd or 4th place winner pick?
My vote is for popsicle / JDFan picking the next one, as redoing a previous challenge might give someone an unfair advantage. Another option would be to use Badmouth's 'All killer, no filler'-lists to find a game.
Done and done. JDFan, it's all you.