So, my "like new, factory sealed" copy of Until Dawn showed up in a beat up case plastered with huge 'inspected by amazon!!" stickers, it was sealed shut with scotch tape, and then RIGHT AFTER those Audible vouchers expired, they dropped the price.
It took considerable moaning, but they did a price adjustment and then comped me the $10 promotion credit back as a "courtesy credit."
I soaked the case in lighter fluid and got all the stickers and tape off. The disc itself was pristine. For ultimately what was ~$5 in gift cards, I'm satisfied. The game itself is amazing. I'm not sure on the replay value but this is one of those "next gen" experiences I feel has been in short supply. Everyone with a PS4 needs to play it.
Stock hard drive is full, but I've got a 1GB 3.5" in an enclosure laying around. I purchased a SATA extension cable and I'll see if I can rig it up.
Here's the game of the week...