Some encouraging news today, I got ShifterMame working! I may have goofed up and pointed the FE to an old version of Mame or something. I installed Mala with the racing layout, pointed everything to where it should point, and boom, I'm playing PP2 fairly accurately. I'm still having pedal issues. I reduced the deadzone to .05, and tinkered with the sensitivity, but I'm still getting a pretty much on or off thing going. I'm going to remove the pedal assembly and clean it up, lube the hinge, and take a look at the springs. It seems like it's not returning back to the 'up' position all the way when you take your foot off. Maybe that's the problem, maybe not, but I'm going to rule it out one way or the other.