I think part of the misunderstanding of SouthPark is that fans just seem(ed) to repeat the same dumb-ass quotes all the time in the same dumb-ass voices giving non-viewers (myself included) the impression that the show was really really stupid and/or just toilet humor.
I love it when people don't watch something and then tell people how bad it is.
For me personally it didn't have anything to do with "telling people how bad it is". Everything I heard about the show from fans
of the show indicated to me that it was a stinking pile of idiocy.
I had no desire to watch South Park at all because I was never given
any indication that it was more than talking pieces of ---steaming pile of meadow muffin--- and annoying high voices saying "You killed Kenny". And the fact that fans of the show seemed to think that particular line was the absolutely funniest thing they'd ever heard didn't make me any more interested at all. It's not exactly a ringing endorsement.
I'm sure there are people who have no interest in watching
As The World Turns, American Idol,
Fear Factor or Pat Robertson on
CBN. You don't have to first watch those things to decide that you don't want to watch them. You're informed about their content by their advertising, articles, word of mouth or whatever and if it's not of interest to you, you don't watch it. There's no obligation to watch any of those shows.
The issue with South Park is that their ads and their fans don't do the show justice. They give no indication that there's anything smart or clever about the show at all. When a friend forced me to watch the SP feature film, I was amazed that it wasn't nearly as stupid as all the South Park fans make it sound. It was really funny.