He called me at home after 9 PM (I wasn't there) filed around 10 PM and escalated within 10 minutes, that's what happened. I did not have time to respond. Spent several hours with Paypal customer service to no avail.
That's my experience regardless of what you may believe. All he had to do was send a package back (booklet and box, no game) with tracking, which he did and Paypal refunded his money.
Looking back at this guys history after the fact he had done this before. I got no satisfaction from Paypal on Ebay regading the issue even though he sent all his offers for the item he wanted to buy outside of ebay through the My Messages feature. They wouldn't even review that.
So again, do what you want I'm not gambling any money on Paypal or Ebay at this point, I don't have the time or energy to set up mutiple accounts just to insure I don't get ---fouled up beyond all recognition---, I'd rather deal with more reputable companies, I'm done.
Bottom line is if your gut tells you something is wrong with a buyer, don't deal with them, don't ignore your instincts.
BTW, to get a little insight on this scam, go to the discussion boards on Ebay, sellers section, this scam is well known there.
Good Luck,
ARCADIAC