The colors match great, no problems there. They look somewhat different in the pictures probably because the marquee is glossy and the CPO has a texture on it (just like a real CPO does which makes it somewhat matte in appearance in the pictures. Again this is a limitation of my very old digital camera I'm sure.
The black on the CPO is a nice dark black, same as the marquee. I can't stress enough how much this looks like a genuine arcade CPO.
Yes I did request the thinner of the two that C.A.G. offers. It bent around the control panel just fine, and seems to adhere to the primed metal very well. I'm not sure how well it would adhere to bare wood. I'd probably give a wood control panel a few coats of primer before I'd apply this stuff to one.
I didn't order the side art and kick panel yet. Since they cost quite a bit more than the marquee and CPO do I wanted to see what their quality was like before I ordered those items. After having seen it, I feel totally comfortable with using C.A.G. for those items as well.
-S