What pbj said. If you have to remove all the buttons anyway, easiest way is to clamp the new plexi to the CP, and route the edge, then use a drill bit to get the flush bit started in the button holes. Contrary to what people say here, if you use a regular 1/2" drill bit but DON'T PUSH, it will melt the acrylic and fall right through without cracking. Then you can use that flush bit to get the button holes finished. Be done by lunch, ready for reassembly.