Star Wars 7 SPOILERS!

Main > Everything Else

<< < (12/34) > >>

wp34:
I liked it better the second time as well. Carrie Fisher about took me out of the movie the first time. The second time I thought she was fine. I was too preoccupied to notice Maz Kanata much the first time but she is an awesome character and example of how CGI can add to a movie.

--- Quote from: dkersten on December 22, 2015, 11:04:00 am ---Here is how it should have ended: First off, when Han dies and Leia feels it, there should have also been a glimpse of a man in robes sitting in a ruined temple (with the mechanical hand so we know it was Luke) who stiffens as if feeling the lightsaber going through his own body, then slumps down as if knowing his failure cost the life of his old friend. At that moment, R2 should come out of his low power mode and start whistling to 3PO, who can't get anyone to pay attention because of the ensuing battle. After the battle settles and people are back and trying to put the pieces back together, 3PO and R2 both finally get the attention of Leia and bring up the map of the galaxy, and instead of a big section that mysteriously nobody recognizes, have the fragment overlay on the known map to show the location of the system Luke was heading to when he first left (which would explain why nobody could recognize the map fragment they had). When Rey returns, she approaches Leia and comforts her, maybe saying a few words about Han's last effort to save their son. Once she says goodbye to Fin, the final scene should be her telling Leia she will send word when she picks up Luke's trail. Then she reassures Leia that she WILL find Luke. Rey and Chewie fly off in the Falcon and enter hyperspace. The end.

It would be reminiscent of the end scene in Empire where Luke was going after Han, and they could open the next movie with Rey, looking like she had spent months searching, finally coming upon the ruins of the temple and finds Luke. It would make it seem like he was actually hard to find and it took both the efforts of the last decade in finding the pieces of the map along with a person strong in the Force searching the right system to find him.

--- End quote ---

The ending didn't bother me but I do like your ending. If they wanted to extend the search for Luke into the next movie yours would have worked better.

Generic Eric:

--- Quote from: wp34 on December 22, 2015, 11:28:02 am ---I liked it better the second time as well. Carrie Fisher about took me out of the movie the first time. The second time I thought she was fine. I was too preoccupied to notice Maz Kanata much the first time but she is an awesome character and example of how CGI can add to a movie.

--- Quote from: dkersten on December 22, 2015, 11:04:00 am ---Here is how it should have ended: First off, when Han dies and Leia feels it, there should have also been a glimpse of a man in robes sitting in a ruined temple (with the mechanical hand so we know it was Luke) who stiffens as if feeling the lightsaber going through his own body, then slumps down as if knowing his failure cost the life of his old friend. At that moment, R2 should come out of his low power mode and start whistling to 3PO, who can't get anyone to pay attention because of the ensuing battle. After the battle settles and people are back and trying to put the pieces back together, 3PO and R2 both finally get the attention of Leia and bring up the map of the galaxy, and instead of a big section that mysteriously nobody recognizes, have the fragment overlay on the known map to show the location of the system Luke was heading to when he first left (which would explain why nobody could recognize the map fragment they had). When Rey returns, she approaches Leia and comforts her, maybe saying a few words about Han's last effort to save their son. Once she says goodbye to Fin, the final scene should be her telling Leia she will send word when she picks up Luke's trail. Then she reassures Leia that she WILL find Luke. Rey and Chewie fly off in the Falcon and enter hyperspace. The end.

It would be reminiscent of the end scene in Empire where Luke was going after Han, and they could open the next movie with Rey, looking like she had spent months searching, finally coming upon the ruins of the temple and finds Luke. It would make it seem like he was actually hard to find and it took both the efforts of the last decade in finding the pieces of the map along with a person strong in the Force searching the right system to find him.

--- End quote ---

The ending didn't bother me but I do like your ending. If they wanted to extend the search for Luke into the next movie yours would have worked better.

--- End quote ---

This ending is better. @dkersten, you should write books or something.

harveybirdman:
I may have to give episode 7 the same treatment I gave the finale of How I met your mother and rewrite it in my head.

I could seem myself endorsing Kersten's version as cannon.

dkersten:

--- Quote from: Generic Eric on December 22, 2015, 12:42:55 pm --- @dkersten, you should write books or something.

--- End quote ---
I've thought about it... ;)

wp34:
Looks like Captain Phasma will be featured more prominently in the next movie.

http://www.cinemablend.com/new/Star-Wars-Episode-8-Feature-Whole-Lot-More-One-Side-Character-101547.html

Navigation

 Message Index

Go to full version