Main > Main Forum

Happ perfect 360 , It's making a crunching noise.

<< < (8/15) > >>

destructor:

--- Quote from: KevSteele on November 16, 2006, 01:21:27 pm ---Kowal,

Like I said, we're going to have to agree to disagree here - I get great diagonals from the P360. You're obviously a fan of fighter games, which I don't play, so there's one reason for disagreement.

Same thing with the SlikStik sticks - just because a Japanese cab has them lower does not make that the "gold standard" height. The P360 review was with the included bat shafts, not the SlikStik balltop ones, which were added after the review was complete.

I stand by the review, and respectfully disagree with your opinions on the diagonals.


--- End quote ---
Did you create this reviews for you or for all players? Or maybe you are HAPP share-holder? :)
90% players say - diagonals are not easy
You and 10% players (maybe HAPP share-holders too :D) say - diagonals are easy
What should be in review?

Or you can write in review: I and 10% players from world say that diagonals are easy, 90% players say that diagonals are hard.

RetroJames:
Actually I reviewed the MagStik and I did have issues at first with hitting the diags but soon adjusted. I still use them today and have no problems at all hitting my mark.

There is a load of subjective material in your statements, something one has to watch out for when reviewing or commenting on controls. You may note I was very careful to frame my opinions as just that.

Aside from faulty craftsmanship, poor engineering, or poor manufacturing, if a stick is well made, whether or not you like it, or it is good for you, is VERY subjective. Height, ability to hit the diags, ball or bat, dustcover ontop or bottom, color, stiffness, throw, none of these can be considered good or bad overall unless there are extreme cases like you can't move the sick or whatever, they are all very much tied to personal taste, ability to adapt, and preference.

Always looking for a factual error to be fixed in reviews, but on the opinion and subjective side I too stand by anything I have written.

RetroJames:

--- Quote from: destructor on November 16, 2006, 01:28:29 pm ---
--- Quote from: KevSteele on November 16, 2006, 01:21:27 pm ---Kowal,

Like I said, we're going to have to agree to disagree here - I get great diagonals from the P360. You're obviously a fan of fighter games, which I don't play, so there's one reason for disagreement.

Same thing with the SlikStik sticks - just because a Japanese cab has them lower does not make that the "gold standard" height. The P360 review was with the included bat shafts, not the SlikStik balltop ones, which were added after the review was complete.

I stand by the review, and respectfully disagree with your opinions on the diagonals.


--- End quote ---



Did you create this reviews for you or for all players? Or maybe you are HAPP share-holder? :)
90% players say - diagonals are not easy
You and 10% players (maybe HAPP share-holders too :D) say - diagonals are easy
What should be in review?

Or you can write in review: I and 10% players from world say that diagonals are easy, 90% players say that diagonals are hard.

--- End quote ---

Ok and now you pissed me off.

'Did you create this reviews for you or for all players? Or maybe you are HAPP share-holder? :)"

I'll thank you to apologize for that remark, it's a ---smurfy--- thing to say. We and the other contributors at RB write these reviews as subjectively as possible, based on our observations, experience, ability, and so forth. Even a hint that we pander to vendors at the expense of the readers really ticks me off. We all work too effing hard to keep RB going to have you or anyone else imply that we are colluding with vendors in our reviews.

KevSteele:
Destructor:

You say 90% of players find diagonals hard on the P360?

I say that 99% of statistics are made up on the spot.  ;)

kowal:
Kevin you need not agree with me. But then many men's opinion. P360 has bad diagonals.
http://forum.arcadecontrols.com/index.php?topic=57724.0
http://forum.arcadecontrols.com/index.php?topic=53037.0

you read  players opinions on SRK?
since this in fighter and shmups has weak diagonals it means that there are weak diagonals. You  not need play in fighters this your matter. If would had good diagonals it was given to play in all games. Not every will buy this joystick to Robotron.

professionals see defect this joystick. How you think who it is right. Do men which tournaments win or someone who plays 4fun in  house?

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page

Go to full version