I like -- if any, you're no Picasso to be honest
-- the last one without all the generic prismatic effect.. but the Lock 'n Chase is best! These overlays are simple, but that's probably what you're going for anyways.
2 things, though, on all of them.. space out the 1 and 2P start buttons (or better yet put them both in the middle), change the font, and just put -- if anything -- the word "START" next to them (maybe in a cooler font).
I mean think about it this way.. even if you just printed out the plain design without the 1/2 markings, effects, or even joystick borders, it will still look nice once you put in the joys, multi-colored buttons, and bolts. You have to keep in mind what the finished product will look and play like.. though I can see the advantage of having the start buttons where they are if you hang out with large-breasted P2s
..
I'm still thinking of putting one of those Morrigan/Lilith lesbian scenes on my CP