I guess the one question I do have would be I understand to not angle the sticks, but the buttons still are no? Or is everything aligned horizontally?
It will be more comfortable if you angle the P3/P4 buttons so players have the same distance reach for their stick and buttons
and P3/P4 are less likely to turn their bodies and bump into P1/P2 while trying to equalize the reach distance.
Rotate the P3 button layout clockwise so that player naturally stands further to the left and rotate the P4 button layout counter-clockwise so that player naturally stands further to the right.
A cardboard or hardboard mockup with the actual controls will allow you to test the inter-player spacing, P3/P4 button layout angles, and button layout patterns. (see
Slagcoin)
One other possible layout consideration is putting all 4 joysticks in a straight line for 2-player
dual joystick games like Smash TV.
- A single player using P1 and P2 sticks would work since they are at the same distance, but the layout in the diagram will cause trouble for 2-player simultaneous gaming because both players' right and left hands will be at different distances.
TL;DR version: P3/P4 buttons angled and all 4 sticks un-angled. (Green is good. Red is bad.)
Scott