Sorry if this should have gone into the project threads just didn't feel like it was quite to that point yet.
Like several others I've been wanting to build a cab. Shocker I know. Got the greenlight from the wife
but with some strict and ... odd requirements. I've got a rough idea of what I want to do and how to make it meet her criteria, even purchased the PC hardware to make sure I can't back out completely, but I've got a few things that I'm still unsure of and want to make sure I'm not going too crazy with the ideas as well.
So the basic rundown after running through designs/plans with the wife (thank you all for posting your build logs) I've got permission to build two cabinets with the following restrictions.
Restrictions for Cab 1 (Basically the wife's):
Must be usable as a coffee table...
Must be usable for table top D&D maps....
Has to have pinball
Has to have wood covers for the CPs and Glass top to prevent damage
Width: 30 - 35 inches
Length: 55 - 60 inches
Height: 24 - 30 inches
4 player in case our daughters want to play
That is a lot of real estate and the D&D map software I put together takes a second screen for the dungeon master so I either have to accomodate that or start fighting with changing the software to work with one monitor.
I was thinking if I went with the two monitor approach I could put in some some sort of hinge/lift that would alllow the second monitor to be used as the backglass for the pinball and I could find some use for it in other scenarios while it's flat. Control schemes, marquee.. as odd as that is in a cocktail style cabinet. The only thing that annoys me with that idea is if there are actually four players one of them is going to be looking over that second monitor and upside down to boot. Would love feedback on any other drawbacks that I should watch out for like leg space as well. I've tried to read through the relevant forum posts but with the site search broken I've been stuck using google site search to try to hunt them down so might have missed some
Restrictions for Cabinet 2:
All gaming systems must be removed from the bedroom
Has to be showcase/pedastal style with seats
Has to be able to be broken down into pieces that can easily be moved (fair enough we have some nasty front stairs on our porch)
Max width: 60 inches
Max height: 72 inches
Max depth: 68 inches
She gave me lots of space to work with but that's in exchange for my VR play area
so going to have to make this worth it.
Since I don't get dedicated cabs I was wondering if there was a database/list of controls used per game so I could sort through what I really want control wise.
I'm kind of torn on 4p for this because I see it being used more than the coffee table anybody have any pros/cons on doing a 4p showcase style vs. a 2p with usb for player 3/4?
For me personally I'd be aiming for three main genres (fighting, racing, shooting/lightgun) but don't want to lock myself out of the occassional tron spree or some of the other games with custom controls. That said I really don't think I'm up for managing modular control panels either, seems like I'd just avoid those games which also seems to be the general concensus. Are there any real downsides to just having usb plugins for those controls, for example the tron stick, or a second spinner (forgotten worlds) other than losing some of the authentic feel? I would like to keep the control panel as clean as possible.
What I'm thinking currently for this one is a 3 piece showcase style at a slightly lower height since it has to have "seats". Control panel is on wheels and detachable, and then an open racing rig that can be folded up, maybe to make the seats? No idea how I would accomplish the folding into seats quite yet but one can dream
Please bash me over the head if I'm over-reaching what's reasonably accomplishable by a novice.
The current state of the lightguns has me torn between ordering the sinden and waiting until November or buillding the DIY aimtrak with the 4 IR sensors can't remember the name of it now, but would welcome any kind of intermediate suggestions since I would really want to see the sinden light gun in action, the idea of the border has me pausing even though I understand the why.
I can handle pretty much anything programming wise, and can do basic electronics so I'm not too worried on that end. But I have absolutely no woodworking skills, luckily the wife actually has some and while she's offered to help. I actually would like to pick up some so I can feel like I at least worked on my cabinet even if she handles hers. Any suggestions outside of Saint's book and the links on the site for going from barely knowing the visual difference in a circular saw and a jigsaw to at least having an idea of what tool to use for each type of cut?
Last two questions, I swear. After reading through the book Saint recommended MDO but most users here seem to recommend plywood but most actually use MDF... Is this just because of cost/finish aspects and the preferred is MDO->Plywood->MDF or are there some types of plywood that seem to do better than MDO for specific aspects like durability?
Finally, I plan on posting build logs but am going to need to work on these simultaneously so the wife can't start backtracking after hers is done, would one or two build threads be preferred?
And for anybody that's made it through this giant wall of text thank you