Now that I look (I never played MK or Tekken and the like BITD) I am surprised to see the original button layouts for those games vs. what most people appear to build.
Stick with the standard "Straight 6" Street Fighter layout for P1 & P2. Just map both middle buttons to Block on Mortal Kombat. Some people add a 7th button for "run" in MK3 and to have the "Neo Geo 4 in a row".
In my experience, MK3 doesn't get played nearly as much as MK2. You can still make one of the middle buttons run and the other block. On the Neo Geo games I have come to prefer hitting the first button in the bottom row with my thumb for the 4th button rather than using a 4th button in the same row. This is after making a neo geo themed cab with four buttons in the top row. I mostly use the 7th button for "tag" in all games that have a tag team feature. To reiterate I recommend the usual straight 6 button layout with concave buttons. I did something else and don't care for it as much.
If I were building a 4 player pedestal, I'd use IL Eurosticks in 4 different colors. Leaf joysticks might be better, but the IL is closer to what I remember playing these types of games with as a kid.
(They probably had Happ Comps in them, but I prefer the Eurostick)
Edit: revisiting the IL Eurostick, it appears they make some pretty cool colors nowadays that could make for a more original looking CP than the old yellow/red/blue/green player layout: https://paradisearcadeshop.com/home/controls/levers/levers-il-industrias-lorenzo/710-il-eurojoystick-series
Also, heed the pic in my signature.
Haha!
Holy crap-
I'm glad I asked for some advice (and happy that you all in particular have seen this and taken the time to reply- so thank you.)
Is there a place I can see a pic of the button layout you are suggesting Badmouth? I see so much of the (obviously more comfortable) 6 button array with an arc to it that I am not sure to drill that or a squared grid of 6 (or 7?).
Sorry to be so dim. There have been rather large blank spaces in my video game life since 1988.
I will certainly check out those sticks.
I was excited to think there was a supplier out on this little rock and after the first I ordered from them Susan had to let me know they moved back to Minnesota.
Nice people.
My advice, for what it's worth.... either build a 4 player beat-em-up cab or a 2 player street fighter cab. Don't build a 4 player street fighter cab. There's just too many buttons. My decades on this forum have taught me that you don't want a jack of all trades, you want a few cabs covering the major genres and then if you have the space some dedicated machines of your choice.
A lot of wisdom in this thread I see-
Looks like I will wind up with 4 MAME cabs here then (cocktail cab for the dining room and then the mulit-panel monster, a 2 player fighter and a 4 player showcase in the Pouty-House) when I can get my act together- since it is obvious all of you gentlemen speak the truth (as Yotsuya indicates.)
The real problem is the space/time continuum at this point-
Mahalo nui loa everyone!
Bobby