If the button are the type which have a plug-in style LED, make sure the LEDs are fully seated and not loose. The vibration from hitting the buttons could cause them to be unseated and get cocked in the holder, which would lead to eventual plunger interference. If they don't seem snug, remove the LED and look at the little fingers in the socket. If they appear to be spread a bit too far apart, insert (with power off, of course) something into the socket to bend them inward toward each other. This will tighten the hold on the LED.
Also make sure that there isn't something in the plunger, like plastic flash, which is causing the inner diameter to be smaller than it should be.