| Main > Everything Else |
| This is the best scene in all of Star Trek, prove me wrong |
| << < (60/62) > >> |
| Grasshopper:
Nope. V was indeed irredeemably awful, and that includes the campfire scene that just made me cringe. One thing I remember from that scene is when Spock says something along the lines of "but life is not a dream". That reply seemed odd when you consider how many Star Trek episodes have featured some sort of simulated reality. You'd think Spock, with his logical and enquiring mind, would at least entertain the possibility that the life we experience is indeed some sort of simulation or "dream". I did enjoy The Motion Picture though. Definitely the most underrated of all the Star Trek movies. |
| Mike A:
You have no soul. |
| Osirus23:
--- Quote from: Grasshopper on October 04, 2020, 09:25:08 am ---Nope. V was indeed irredeemably awful, and that includes the campfire scene that just made me cringe. --- End quote --- Yeah, those scenes were hamfisted. The overall writing of the film was awful partly because of the writers strike of '88. The same strike that wrecked season 2 of TNG and resulted in the season finale being a ---smurfing--- clip show :lol |
| Howard_Casto:
Yeah there's something wrong with both of you. It's not about the writing, it's about good actors that have worked together for years getting the opportunity to act off of each other in small intimate scenes. That being said the writing wasn't ham-fisted, it was Shakespearian... as in other the top on purpose for dramatic effect. What part of anyone's acting style in any Star Trek film ever reads "subtle" to you guys? |
| Vigo:
I'm with Mike and Howard. V suffers from a lot of problems, but the Kirk, McCoy & Spock chemistry is top notch. It is the culmination a friendship established over the series and previous movies. For everything the Star Trek franchise has produced, that character chemistry has never been equaled. |
| Navigation |
| Message Index |
| Next page |
| Previous page |