Ok, I fixed two problems and it worked.
One, my components cable was broken af.
And two, my VGA output is Analog_0 instead of Analog_1 for some reason. According to the guide it was supposed to be _1 since it has a DVI port that should've been the main one, but it happened to be the opposite on my particular card.
So that's the lesson from this thread. Check your cables, and try all outputs on vmmaker.
Thanks anyway to the whole community for putting up all the resources that led me to finally having this working!
Fixed the links for you.
Thank you! It's been awhile, and forgot to preview the post