Well I don't know either of you, and I'm pretty new to this hobby, so have no vested interest in this internet pissing match, but Nephasth, seriously if you don't want to pay that much spend your money elsewhere.
Personally I am constantly amazed at how cheap inexpensive everything in the buttons and joystick departments is.
Randy, I'm always in favor of more options, I may not ever use them, but it's nice having the option.