| Main > Everything Else |
| BYOAC Talking Dead - Walking Dead Season 5 |
| << < (37/84) > >> |
| menace:
While I thought it was interesting, the whole carol thing just didn't seem to fit with her character thus far--unless she has totally snapped and is in the process of going around the bend (like sasha)- The other part I thought was stupid was the whole sequence with the horse--so you are telling me that a 850lb animal couldn't outrun a shambling bunch of mindless weak rotting people??? People (living strong healthy people) die from getting kicked, or run over from horses...I thought it was just a useless sequence... |
| Rick:
--- Quote from: menace on March 10, 2015, 07:26:54 am ---While I thought it was interesting, the whole carol thing just didn't seem to fit with her character thus far --- End quote --- I disagree - I believe that Carol has grown into this character over time. She's almost coming in-line with Morgan, in regards to her survival abilities. I think that she assessed the situation perfectly and took the only possible path she could. She needed to instill the fear of god into that kid, or else, they were doomed - cookies weren't going to do it, only having him fear for his life would have any chance of working. |
| menace:
I don't discount her survival abilities--they even planted the tongue in cheek when that guy was asking her if she would like shooting lessons (which I thought was funny) but so far carol has been the most nurturing of the group towards the kids--for her to go all evil clown fits the story and does the job but it still really stuck out as something outside of the person we have seen so far. I think how they are showing sasha's spindown is pretty good and frankly i'm surprised more of them aren't almost catatonic. |
| Rick:
--- Quote from: menace on March 10, 2015, 08:37:54 am ---they even planted the tongue in cheek when that guy was asking her if she would like shooting lessons (which I thought was funny) but so far carol has been the most nurturing of the group towards the kids--for her to go all evil clown fits the story and does the job but it still really stuck out as something outside of the person we have seen so far. --- End quote --- Carol has been "on guard" and playing a different persona since she's arrived. Look at how she handed in her guns at the beginning - handling them like they could go off at any moment, and that she was glad to be rid of them. She's playing a role, and while I don't believe she would actually carry out what she told the kid - she was the one who set the two "soon to turns" on fire at the prison. She's harder than you're giving her credit for. |
| JMB:
I didn't think it was out of character for Carol. It is definitely what she has become over the years. From teaching the kids in the jail how to kill to knowing that she needed to kill the blond girl and doing it. |
| Navigation |
| Message Index |
| Next page |
| Previous page |