| Main > Main Forum |
| The 2013 BYOAC User Choice Awards needs your nominations! |
| << < (13/27) > >> |
| Nephasth:
--- Quote from: Le Chuck on January 04, 2014, 10:08:16 am ---This isn't an issue of "sjaak made a game but there's no download link waah!" it's that sjaak's game doesn't really fit the bill of what the software category is all about. Just like his Pac Man Battle Royale it was built for a specific build and we think it should be judged within that build since it isn't a stand alone item. --- End quote --- I'm pretty sure if Banana Royale was completed, it'd win software for sure. |
| Nephasth:
I'd like to nominate Ond for the Forum Contribution category for his Metropolis tutorial. |
| Le Chuck:
--- Quote from: Nephasth on January 04, 2014, 01:42:17 pm --- --- Quote from: Le Chuck on January 04, 2014, 10:08:16 am ---This isn't an issue of "sjaak made a game but there's no download link waah!" it's that sjaak's game doesn't really fit the bill of what the software category is all about. Just like his Pac Man Battle Royale it was built for a specific build and we think it should be judged within that build since it isn't a stand alone item. --- End quote --- I'm pretty sure if Banana Royale was completed, it'd win software for sure. --- End quote --- Maybe a "home brew game" category? Would need enough competition tho. I really liked that one alien shooter that guy made this year. |
| Nephasth:
That's the thing, though. (If it were finished) You'd have to put it somewhere in an existing category, and software would have to be it until there were enough other similar projects to create a new category. Hell, look at the small size category so far (I'm sure it'll get broken up, but...) there is a wide range of types of projects represented in that category so far. Speaking of... Pinball Unleashed is thrown in the small size, yet v-pins are defined as full size. |
| yotsuya:
--- Quote from: Nephasth on January 04, 2014, 03:23:25 pm ---That's the thing, though. (If it were finished) You'd have to put it somewhere in an existing category, and software would have to be it until there were enough other similar projects to create a new category. Hell, look at the small size category so far (I'm sure it'll get broken up, but...) there is a wide range of types of projects represented in that category so far. Speaking of... Pinball Unleashed is thrown in the small size, yet v-pins are defined as full size. --- End quote --- Good eye, Neph. Fixed. |
| Navigation |
| Message Index |
| Next page |
| Previous page |