Main > Main Forum

9 buttons per player ...

Pages: << < (2/5) > >>

Xiaou2:


--- Quote --- You have to reach over a bunch of gratuitous steering wheels to play Streets of Rage? Pass. 
--- End quote ---

 While the thing isnt pretty, and has some design oddities.. clearly from the video, theres no need to reach over or around controls. (as is the case with most peoples 4ways, spinners, and trackballs , where often,  your arms would lay on buttons and other controllers)   The wheels are all under the players arms.   Similarly, you dont usually stand with your crotch against a machine.  Most will stand at 3 to 8 inches away from the Cp... depending on overhang, depth of controllers, etc.

 I seriously dont understand peoples need to poke at others works.  If you dont like it.. then dont look at it.  It clearly wasnt built for You and Your enjoyment / hate.



Ginsu Victim:

Oh yeah, this cab! I'd made a quick and easy image (hence, the crappiness) for it back in the day:


keilmillerjr:


--- Quote from: Xiaou2 on July 17, 2013, 09:11:10 pm ---
--- Quote --- You have to reach over a bunch of gratuitous steering wheels to play Streets of Rage? Pass. 
--- End quote ---

 While the thing isnt pretty, and has some design oddities.. clearly from the video, theres no need to reach over or around controls. (as is the case with most peoples 4ways, spinners, and trackballs , where often,  your arms would lay on buttons and other controllers)   The wheels are all under the players arms.   Similarly, you dont usually stand with your crotch against a machine.  Most will stand at 3 to 8 inches away from the Cp... depending on overhang, depth of controllers, etc.

 I seriously dont understand peoples need to poke at others works.  If you dont like it.. then dont look at it.  It clearly wasnt built for You and Your enjoyment / hate.

--- End quote ---

I can tell you that I clearly remember when I used to go to arcades cleaning directly against the cabinet. I'd always have one knee slightly bent and my leg above the knee leaning against the cabinet where the control panel didn't stick out. This made it awkward for my feet. Cabinets who's panel did stick out, sometimes I'd rest a hip on the edge of the control panel. Some cabinets had hanging control panels, but sides that fully extended forwards, making my feet boxed in. Maybe my weird playing positions was due to my height (tall).

No matter how you look at it, that machine is one giant inconvenience due to the creator trying to include it all. You don't see an iPad including a printer, even though it can print, do you? No. Because it would be awkward to include the two together in one unit, even though they work together. Some times less is more.

DaveMMR:


--- Quote from: Xiaou2 on July 17, 2013, 09:11:10 pm ---
--- Quote --- You have to reach over a bunch of gratuitous steering wheels to play Streets of Rage? Pass. 
--- End quote ---

 While the thing isnt pretty, and has some design oddities.. clearly from the video, theres no need to reach over or around controls. (as is the case with most peoples 4ways, spinners, and trackballs , where often,  your arms would lay on buttons and other controllers)   The wheels are all under the players arms.   Similarly, you dont usually stand with your crotch against a machine.  Most will stand at 3 to 8 inches away from the Cp... depending on overhang, depth of controllers, etc.
--- End quote ---

Okay, first of all, I need to introduce you to my friend hyperbole. Shake hands and get to know him and you won't have to point out the obvious. Yes, I clearly saw the player working the stick without straining to overcome the obstacles. Now let's excuse Mr. Hyperbole from the room and talk serious. While I never measured my standing distance from the controls, I do know that I have, in the heat of the game, on more than one occasion, encroached upon the edge of my control panel. And when that happens, I thank the heavens I didn't stick a steering wheel where my crotch ended up during said sudden encroachment. And therein lies the other problem: who wants to touch a steering wheel that had some dudes sack resting on it while he was playing a heated game of Streets of Rage?


--- Quote --- I seriously dont understand peoples need to poke at others works.  If you dont like it.. then dont look at it.  It clearly wasnt built for You and Your enjoyment / hate.

--- End quote ---

How can I tell I don't like it if I don't look at it? It's not that I can unlook at it. Also, you must have missed the part where I said:


--- Quote ---Eh, the builder's proud of it so to each his own I suppose. Not a design I would recommend anyone copying though...
--- End quote ---

The point of my comment was, "sorry, it's not a good design to emulate" and I tried to be as constructive as possible with that reasoning. (Yeah, there was a little sarcasm about the lack of paint but that's not really the major issue here anyhow.) If pointing it out saves one new builder from wasting time and money on poor design choices, then it's served its purpose.

And, in all fairness, I tried to wrap my head around that automated keyboard before calling it out and I still cannot see how that is at all usable. Do you type on it, run around to the front to check for typos and then run back to the keyboard ear to hit enter? Okay, maybe it's removable? But then why even bother with the mechanics if you just have to pull it off anyhow? It is seriously wrinkling my brain!

Okay, that last part was maybe not very constructive and possible venomous but it seriously wasted precious minutes thinking of its practical application.

P.S.: Compared to some of the YouTube comments, we're all actually really mature.

shponglefan:


--- Quote from: Xiaou2 on July 17, 2013, 09:11:10 pm ---I seriously dont understand peoples need to poke at others works.  If you dont like it.. then dont look at it.  It clearly wasnt built for You and Your enjoyment / hate.
--- End quote ---

If someone is taking the time to upload a video to YouTube, clearly they are looking to broadcast it to the public.  And thus will invite critiques, whether positive or negative.

And there is arguably value in negative critiques, because it gives others an opportunity to learn what not to do.

Pages: << < (2/5) > >>

Go to full version