Uh, what are the terms of service on something like that? I feel like if the board gives the option to delete or change your own post, and someone does it, maybe it shouldn't be reversed without communicating with them. When you reinstate, are you concentrating on information posts and filtering out snarky comments? Even though I work from home and am mostly my own boss, I am sensitive about what I post because it's not that hard to link back to me. I don't try to hide my identity/location/line of work. I try to refrain from immature or controversial content (except with regard to Arnel Pineda.) I assume everything I post is on the internet forever. However, the rulebook needs to be clear IMO. Add it to the terms that your input belongs to the forum after 30 days or something. forgive me if this is already covered in the forum rules, I didn't go back and check.
I'm not sure that PBJ shouldn't be grandfathered in and his/her posts left deleted if he took the time to do so, prior to updated rules. It would be easier to evaluate if he would make a quick post with his reasoning, but that's his/her choice. I agree that it's annoying to have your own threads confused by deleted posts. I generally prefer BYOAC with a side of PBJ, even though he's said some dumb stuff that pissed me off. Generally I have been entertained and sometimes even enlightened.