Main > Everything Else

Awards Project

<< < (11/21) > >>

Generic Eric:

--- Quote from: Le Chuck on February 21, 2012, 04:53:34 pm ---
--- Quote from: Generic Eric on February 21, 2012, 04:41:54 pm ---Can this be accomplished similarly to the SMF trader system?  For example, if I wanted my project attached with my profile, I could submit my project, and if someone wanted to comment on my project, they could.  Or perhaps, they could just give a thumbs up or down.  

I'd offer one of my projects up, but neither are complete.  Would anyone in this thread offer their cabinet up for the demo round of how this is gonna go?  Limit the judging to the participants in this thread?

--- End quote ---

I started the thread so it wouldn't be good form if I wasn't willing to put my money where my mouth was so to speak.  Darkade is on the chopping block for whoever would like to take a swing.   

--- End quote ---


There sure is a lot of sausage making in this thread.   

Presuming that the DARKADE will be reviewed first, do you feel your project announcement thread is sufficient, or would you resubmit it with all the details presented with out other member's comments in between your posts?  As I imagine this, a project that was being judged wouldn't have any commentary until the end. 

DaveMMR:

--- Quote from: Generic Eric on February 21, 2012, 05:10:54 pm ---
--- Quote from: Le Chuck on February 21, 2012, 04:53:34 pm ---
--- Quote from: Generic Eric on February 21, 2012, 04:41:54 pm ---Can this be accomplished similarly to the SMF trader system?  For example, if I wanted my project attached with my profile, I could submit my project, and if someone wanted to comment on my project, they could.  Or perhaps, they could just give a thumbs up or down.  

I'd offer one of my projects up, but neither are complete.  Would anyone in this thread offer their cabinet up for the demo round of how this is gonna go?  Limit the judging to the participants in this thread?

--- End quote ---

I started the thread so it wouldn't be good form if I wasn't willing to put my money where my mouth was so to speak.  Darkade is on the chopping block for whoever would like to take a swing.   

--- End quote ---


There sure is a lot of sausage making in this thread.   

Presuming that the DARKADE will be reviewed first, do you feel your project announcement thread is sufficient, or would you resubmit it with all the details presented with out other member's comments in between your posts?  As I imagine this, a project that was being judged wouldn't have any commentary until the end. 

--- End quote ---

Would it be easier to start a new thread with a brief outline and pictures of the Darkade (started by Le Chuck of course) and do a round of reviews there?  Or squeeze it in this thread? And who's submitting their judging commentary?

Le Chuck:
Well that's kind of a toss up and depends on if it's voluntary or community recommended.  Idealy I wouldn't want to make everybody recreate a post just for the review but I think that a certain level of standardization would be useful.  Maybe have it optional.  "If recommended please open a thread with the following format.  If you decide not to do this we will still review your project just the same but appreciate the help as we have a lot of these to go through"

If somebody wants to recommend a format I'll gladly post.  Here or elsewhere. Format should either be category specific or generic enough to get the pertinent information no matter the category.

Eventually if we decide to go live I'd like to see this have it's own area in the forums as a board or a child board and then a private child board for the currrent panel to make their sausage in private.    

Generic Eric:

--- Quote from: DaveMMR on February 21, 2012, 05:27:20 pm ---
--- Quote from: Generic Eric on February 21, 2012, 05:10:54 pm ---
--- Quote from: Le Chuck on February 21, 2012, 04:53:34 pm ---
--- Quote from: Generic Eric on February 21, 2012, 04:41:54 pm ---Can this be accomplished similarly to the SMF trader system?  For example, if I wanted my project attached with my profile, I could submit my project, and if someone wanted to comment on my project, they could.  Or perhaps, they could just give a thumbs up or down.  

I'd offer one of my projects up, but neither are complete.  Would anyone in this thread offer their cabinet up for the demo round of how this is gonna go?  Limit the judging to the participants in this thread?

--- End quote ---

I started the thread so it wouldn't be good form if I wasn't willing to put my money where my mouth was so to speak.  Darkade is on the chopping block for whoever would like to take a swing.   

--- End quote ---


There sure is a lot of sausage making in this thread.   

Presuming that the DARKADE will be reviewed first, do you feel your project announcement thread is sufficient, or would you resubmit it with all the details presented with out other member's comments in between your posts?  As I imagine this, a project that was being judged wouldn't have any commentary until the end. 

--- End quote ---

Would it be easier to start a new thread with a brief outline and pictures of the Darkade (started by Le Chuck of course) and do a round of reviews there?  Or squeeze it in this thread? And who's submitting their judging commentary?

--- End quote ---

I should have just suggested a new thread instead of all those extra words above.

CheffoJeffo:
FWIW, I think that BobA is one of the most positive contributors here and chimes in to help everybody. He reminds what I *should* be doing here.

Even I don't have the balls to ask him to come in and judge other people's work. He's a good guy -- don't put him on the spot like that.

Has ANYBODY actually asked saint what he thinks ?

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page

Go to full version