And people say I'm stuffy. At least that person didn't go on an on about it, they just expressed their opinion, briefly.
Adding my own experience, here:
I felt the unit was fine for what it was supposed to do. The controllers worked fine, though the throw was long (far too long for me). Like expressed in the Retroblast review, I thought the buttons were the same noise level as HAPP, just higher-pitched. (...and perhaps a slight larger diametre, it seemed... Anyways, I actually liked the actuation of these better than HAPP buttons, cos though they had similar travel, they actuated at the bottom of the stroke.) The overal design was definitely not arcade level quality, but very sturdy, and I REALLY liked the finish (powder coat, perhaps). The bolts through the panel marred this, though.
Technically, the only problem is not having a true 4-way (or 4-way assumable) stick. (Or 4-way assumable - like the P360, as it has no switch feedback. Supplemental: however, in this latter case, since diagonals feel the same as standard directions, it's really an issue of MAME that you can't properly set the controls so that you can use the same stick for 4 and 8-way use.)