Main > Everything Else

Retro rated: Magnificent Seven

(1/3) > >>

danny_galaga:
"I don't think I ever rode shotgun on a hearse before!"  ;D

Watched this on the telly last night. I hadn't seen it before, but I knew it was based on Seven Samurai, one of my favourite movies. It even mentions that fact in the opening credits! It had a lot to live up to in that regard. On the plus side is the ensemble cast. I love how Yul Bruyner walks exactly the same way as he did later in Westworld, where he plays a robot cowboy :duckhunt

The score is great, really matching the moods of the movie. I didn't know the Marloboro Man theme was from this movie.

Many scenes from the original appear in one form or another in Magnificent Seven. The wanna-be warrior who tags along for instance. Later he infiltrates the raiders camp. I haven't watched Seven Samurai for a while. You need to set a lot of time aside for that epic. Might do so again while Magnificent Seven is fresh in my mind.

What lets it down for me is how it compares to Seven Samurai. There is so much pathos in the Japanese version. Even the circumstance that we find the warriors in at the beginning is so pathetic. Our cowboys on the other hand are down, but certainly not reduced to working for a handful of rice! Also, the utterly brilliant battle in the rain wasn't emulated in the Western version. Sounds like a small point but it is one of the best scenes ever for me.

3.5/5



--- Quote ---my score for recent movies you may have seen:

  5/5 - The Way Back, The Kings Speech, Michael Clayton, In Bruges, Gran Torino, Mary and Max

4.5/5 - Taken, Iron Man, Reign Over Me, Watchmen, The girl with the dragon tattoo

  4/5 - True Grit, Traitor, Bedtime Stories, Sunshine, pineapple express

3.5/5 - 300, Max Payne, You dont mess with the Zohan, Yes Man

  3/5 - That new Indiana Jones flick, Disturbia, That new TMNT flick,

2.5/5 - Angels and Demons

  2/5 - The Love Guru. Note: My 2 is probably someone elses 1. Just leaving room for worse!

--- End quote ---

wp34:
I have not seen this in a while but remember being really let down the first time I finally did.  I'm a big western fan and had always thought this to be a classic.  Expectations may have been too high.  I'll need to watch it again. 

Vigo:
I love both Seven Samurai and the Magnificent Seven. I try my hardest not to compare the two because they each put out a different feeling. Magnificent seven is a genuine classic in the Western Genre, but it is sort of a "Ocean's Eleven" Classic, where it relies on a compilation of brilliant, veteran actors to drive the movie.

It is also hard to emulate the distinct style of Kurosawa, who I would list in my top ten directors of all time, and this would be one of his finest movies.

If you want to see another Kurosawa piece gone western, Watch Yojimbo and Fist full of Dollars. Both are amazing movies.

danny_galaga:

--- Quote from: Vigo on September 19, 2011, 12:44:30 pm ---I love both Seven Samurai and the Magnificent Seven. I try my hardest not to compare the two because they each put out a different feeling. Magnificent seven is a genuine classic in the Western Genre, but it is sort of a "Ocean's Eleven" Classic, where it relies on a compilation of brilliant, veteran actors to drive the movie.

It is also hard to emulate the distinct style of Kurosawa, who I would list in my top ten directors of all time, and this would be one of his finest movies.

If you want to see another Kurosawa piece gone western, Watch Yojimbo and Fist full of Dollars. Both are amazing movies.



--- End quote ---

I think I've only seen 'Fistful of Dollars' once as a kid. Incidentally, one of my favourite movies of all time is 'The Good the Bad and the Ugly'. I only revisited it last year and it really has stood the test of time. I might have to make your comparison as shamefully I've only seen the one B & W Kurasawa flick. I have seen Ran, which is awesome. The westerns inspired by Kurasawa are interesting in the fact that Kurasawa drew inspiration from Westerns in the first place  ;D  Or Shakespeare in the case of Ran.

wp34:
I didn't realize Kurosawa did Hidden Fortress as well.  Lucas credits that movie as a major influence for Star Wars.  I've only seen parts of Fortress but you can see where Lucas got the inspiration for the R2 and Threepio if you are looking for it.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

Go to full version