spystyle: I wasn't making any demands, only suggestions. I'm sorry I didn't work to make that more clear.
Jakobud: My concern isn't for a true exact replicas, because as you say purists will never be happy. But enough information to build a complete cab in one shot for the non-carpenters out there is worth considering.
Things like original monitor position, speaker location, etc. fall into this category of desired information I would think.
Those that are looking for "similar-but customized" can customize even if provided with the rough 'original' layout information. But those that want a machine that looks (give-or-take) exactly like a Q*Bert (for example) except it's a MAME cab in disguise can't get there from scratch with just the side dimensions. The monitor mounting angle inside a Pac-Man, is completely different than that in a Defender as well.
Providing the monitor shelf, speaker shelf/marquee shelf, etc. will save people some trial & error when building their cabs when they just want to build & go, and not have to find out the hard way that they can't hear their speaker well with it just bolted under the monitor or that their monitor neck just went crunch because it was sticking too close to the rear door.
If all people need is the side template, heck, take any snapshot of any cab side, rotate image to level the base, edge tool, crop & fill to shape, hunt down PDF manual to get height, resize image based on that height, and you're done in two to five minutes. Output to HPGL, and 5 minutes of CNC routing action later you have the side of anything you want. I've done this several times just yanking images off eBay.
Of course I wouldn't expect information like the 2"x2" braces/supports or any of the board-cage type information since most ppl will just toss the PC into the base of the cab, or use PCB feet where-ever they're comfortable with them.
Anyway, again, just my opinion/take on the matter and everyone has opinions.
On a related note, If you want the dimensions for any of the following let me know:
Crystal Castles
Pole Position (I have so many of these that you will definately see some of the plastic molded control panels up on eBay after a while)
Atari Football "cocktail" (rather tall cocktail, I like it)
Star Castle
Defender
Millipede
Pac-Man
Space Zap
Return of the Jedi
Capcom Street Fighter II: TNC
Simpsons (4P)
Chase HQ
Phoenix
Pleaids
Nintendo (DK, Mario, etc.)
Turbo (upright)
Mechanized Attack (big dual mounted gun cab)
Dig Dug
Gunsmoke
Thanks again for all your effort Jakobud.
Are any of these "plans" going to be completed?
Most people will need more than sides if they want to build a replica cabinet. I'd think things such as coin door cutout, monitor shelf, marquee/speaker shelf, and such should be included at minimum.
I have wondered about this as I have been drawing up so many plans for cabinets. It seemed that more people were generally interested in the basic shape and look of the game.
I mean, if you wanted to make a real truely genuine replica cabinet there is a LOT you would have to measure on an original. Like exactly where and how the monitor was mounted, what type of framing was used on the inside and the dimensions for all the internal mounting blocks, PCB mounting location and dimensions, power supply mounting dimensions, how the wires were mounted and run inside the cabinet, etc etc... the list goes on and on if you want to make a cabinet that is exactly like an original... and you are never going to get completely accurate dimensions for all these things unless you have access to the original cabinet blueprints from the original manufacturer....
Anyways, no matter how exact you try to make a 'replica' cabinet, it is still just a replica and not original and if a dimension is off by even a 1/8" that's enough justification to complain about it if you are truely wanting it to be EXACTLY like an original...
In the end, it seems like people want to just customize the cabinet a little bit here and there but they want the general shape of the originals.